Immune Response to Immunodominant Mycobacterium tuberculosis Antigen ESAT6- Derived Peptide is HLA-Haplotype Dependent..Veena Taneja*
Michele Smart1, Marshall Behrens1, Luckey David1, Catherine Conway1, Veena Taneja*1,2
1Department of Immunology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN 55905, USA.
2Department of Medicine, Division of Rheumatology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN 55905.
The antigenic proteins of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) have been defined. We used synthetic peptides of secreted antigens, early secreted antigenic target 6 (ESAT-6) and cultural filtrate protein-10 (CFP-10), of Mtb and characterized the immune response in context of HLA genes. Humanized mice lacking endogenous class II molecules but expressing various human DR and DQ HLA transgenes singly or as a haplotype were used to study the HLA-mediated immune response to peptides. Our observations showed that the overall response to the promiscuous ESAT-6 31-45 peptide may be dependent on the HLA haplotype rather than a single DR or DQ molecule. Further, our data showed that HLA transgenes generated a highly variable TH response to this promiscuous peptide. This provides an explanation for the variability of the bacillus Calmette-Guerin (BCG) vaccine. Our data highlights the use of HLA transgenic mice for determining the pathogenicity or therapeutic nature of a peptide in the context of HLA alleles.
Keywords: HLA; Humanized Mice ESAT-6; CFP-10; Tuberculosis
Major histocompatibility Complex (MHC) encodes for the HLA class II genes, the most polymorphic genes in the human genome. HLA class II molecules on antigen presenting cells are responsible for antigen presentation to CD4+ T cells and generate an immune response to pathogens. Recently it was suggested that CD4 T cells, positively selected on the basis of class II alleles, are predetermined to generate a specific immune response . Accordingly, HLA class II alleles may also determine variability in generating a response to infectious agents.We are exposed to many microbes, some beneficial and other pathogenic. Evolutionarily, class II alleles that confer resistance to infections or clear infections efficiently are selected. Thus HLA polymorphism has been associated with susceptibility to various infectious agents.
Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) is a pathogen that has been able to evade the immune system and cause Tuberculosis (TB) in some individuals. Tuberculosis (TB) is a leading health problem in the world, specially developing countries. Despite availability of the vaccine, approximately 2 million deaths occur every year (http://www.who.int/tb/en/) making it one of the leading causes of death due to infectious agent. Thus there is a need to understand the hostpathogen interaction and resulting immune response for vaccine development. The host factors that determine the susceptibility or resistance to TB are not clear. There are studies showing the HLA-DR2/DQ6 haplotype with susceptibility to develop tuberculosis in many populations while other have shown the presence of DRB1*04/DQB1*03 and DRB1*14, DRB1*16 [2-5]. One study has suggested that HLA-DQ alleles with homozygous Aspartic (Asp) acid at codon 57 are associated with pulmonary tuberculosis . Even though no specific HLA allele indicative of disease resistance or susceptibility in all ethnic populations has emerged, the studies suggest a role of HLA class II alleles in pathogenesis.
Mycobacterium tuberculosis secretes proteins that have been suggested to be involved in generating an immune response. These proteins have been tested for potential vaccine candidates. The major secretory antigens of Mtb are Ag-85, early secreted antigenic target 6 (ESAT-6) and cultural filtrate protein-10 (CFP-10). Among the major antigens, ESAT-6 and CFP-10 show the most reactivity and are involved in T cell activation as well as macrophage inhibition , suggesting epitopes from these proteins may be promiscuous in HLA binding and presentation. Immunodominant epitopes of ESAT-6 and CFP-10 and their HLA restriction has recently been defined . Response to CFP-10 has been significantly associated with the presence of DR15  while DQ polymorphism at codon 57 is associated with susceptibility to pulmonary TB in a population . In humans it is difficult to determine the role of HLA molecules in vivo due to genetic complexity. We have previously shown that these HLA transgenic (Tg) mice recognize the same epitopes of Antigen85 as human cell lines, making them valuable for the determination of epitopes for generating vaccines [10, 11]. In this study we have used humanized mice expressing specific HLA transgenes to determine reactivity by various HLA molecules to EAST-6 and CFP-10 epitopes.
The generation of mice carrying human HLA transgenes, DQ8 (DQA1*0301/DQB1*0302), DQ6 (DQA1*0103/DQB1*0601), DR4 (DRB1*0401 and *0402), and DR3(DRB1*0301) mice have been described previously andall mice have been characterized and published [12,13]. All mice are endogenous class II knockout (AEo). In addition to single Tg mice, double transgenic mice expressing DR and DQ genes, DR3/DQ8, DR4/DQ8, and DR3/DQ6 were also used. Double Tg mice were generated by mating single Tg mice and selecting for the presence ofboth alleles. Thus all strains have the same background except for the HLA gene construct. Mice of both sexes (8-12 weeks of age) used in this study were bred and maintained in the pathogen-free Immunogenetics Mouse Colony at the Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN in accordance withthe Animal Use and Care Committee. All the experiments included littermate controls and were carried out with the approval of the Institute’s Animal use and care committee.
Peptides were synthesized and purified at Mayo ClinicPeptide Facility ESAT-6 amino acid (aa) 31-45, EGKQSLTKLAAAWGGand 46-60, SGSEAYQGVQQKWDA CFP-10 aa 16-30, GNFERISGDLKTQID and 41-55 GQWRGAAGTAAQAAV
T cell proliferation Assay
In other experiments, splenic cells from mice primed withESAT-6 31-45 were also cultured with LPS (10ug/ml) andsupernatants were collected for measuring cytokines.
Measurement of cytokines:
Results and Discussion
Bacillus Calmette Guerin (BCG) has been used forvaccination against TB for more than 50 years but its poorefficacy in some populations has generated a need fordeveloping new vaccines. Antigenic proteins of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, ESAT-6 and CFP-10, have been shown to elicit an immune response in tuberculosis patients. The TH1 dependent production of IFN-γ has beensuggested to protect against TB. A screening of ESAT-6derived overlapping peptides showed that human CD4+T cell lines produced IFN-γ in response to challenge with peptides encompassing aa 22-65 . However, the proliferation data was not consistent, as not all patients sharing a HLA haplotype generated response to the ESAT-6 peptides. For a vaccine to be successful, the antigen has to be a promiscuous binder and immunogenic. In humans, due to linkage disequilibrium between HLA-DR and DQ alleles, it is difficult to determine the role of the HLA genes. To overcome this issue, we used mice expressinga single HLA transgene or HLA haplotype to determine the immune response to ESAT-6 and CFP-10 derived peptides. Our previous study has shown that transgenicmice generate a similar response to BCG-derived antigen85 suggesting transgenic mice to be a good model to study epitopes for vaccines for TB.
Presence of Asp57 reduces response to the immunodominant peptides of ESAT-6 and CFP-10
Figure 1. ESAT-6 31-45 is a promiscuous peptide. Lymph node cell proliferation to ESAT-6 and CFP-10 derived peptides in a recall response in vitro. Mice were primed with individual peptides, N=3/strain. Data are presented as Mean±SEM. S.I.= Stimulation Index
HLA-DR alleles can present ESAT-6 immunodominantepitope
Cytokine response to ESAT-6 is HLA dependent
Figure 2. TH response to ESAT-6- 31-45 peptide is HLA dependent. Supernatants from the cultures with ESAT-6-31-45 were used for measuring IFN-γ (TH1), IL-10 (TH2) and IL-17 and IL-12(p40) (TH17) by ELISA. Data are presented as Mean±SEM
Complementation between HLA-DQ and DR modulates immune response to peptides
Next we determined if cytokine production is also modulated to this peptide. Both haplotype positive strains did not produce any TH17 cytokines (Figure 3B). *0401/ DQ8 mice produced high IFN-γ with very low levels of IL-10 while *0402/DQ8 mice produced very low levels of IFN-γ with no IL-10. This data suggests that HLA haplotype needs to be considered for the immune response rather than a single HLA gene.
Figure 3. Interaction between HLA-DR and DQ molecules in Haplotype transgenic mice modulates immune response to the immunodominant ESAT-6 31- 45 peptide. A) Lymph node cell proliferation to ESAT-6-31-45 peptide in a recall response in vitro, N=2/strain. B) Supernatants from culture from were used to measure cytokine response. No Th17 response was detected in both strains. Data are presented as Mean±SEM. S.I. =Stimulation Index
Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) is a ligand for bacterial proteinlipopolysaccharide (LPS). We tested if transgenic mice immunized with ESAT-6 31-45 peptide still have the capability of generating a TLR4-mediated response. Spleniccells isolated from ESAT-6-primed mice were cultured with LPS and tested the supernatants for cytokines (Figure 4). Interestingly, even though DQ6 mice did not produce IFN-γin response to ESAT-6 peptide, the TLR4-mediated response was intact with high IFN-γ production. Both strains, DQ8 and DQ6, produced similar profile of cytokines. Similarly, all 3 DR transgenic mice tested produced all cytokines,however DR3 mice produced much higher IFN-γ and IL-12(p40) compared to both strains of DR4 mice.
Figure 4. TLR4-mediated cytokine response in ESAT-6-31-45 primed mice. Splenic cells isolated from peptide primed mice were challenged in vitro with LPS and supernatants were used to measure cytokines by ELISA in A) DQ mice and B) DR mice. Data are presented as Mean±SEM
An interaction between DR and DQ genes led to a change in TLR4-mediated cytokine profile as *0401/DQ8 and *0402/DQ8 mice produced much higher levels of IL-17, IL- 12(p40) and IFN-γ while no IL-10 was produced in both strains (Figure 5).
Figure 5. TLR4 mediated cytokine production is modulated by complementation between DR and DQ molecules in haplotype positive humanized mice. Splenic cells isolated from peptide primed mice were challenged in vitro with LPS and proliferation was measured. Supernatants were used to measure cytokines by ELISA. A) *0401/DQ8 and *0402/DQ8 mice produce IFN-γ in response to TLR4-mediated activation of cells. B) In vitro proliferation to LPS in ESAT-6-31 primed mice and C) Comparison of IFN-γ in single HLA transgene and haplotype positive mice. Data are presented as Mean±SEM.
*0401/DQ8 mice produced significantly higher levels of pro-inflammatory IL-12 (P40) compared to *0402/DQ8 in response to LPS (Figure 5A). Interestingly, the presence of *0401/DQ8 haplotype is associated with susceptibility to rheumatoid arthritis in humans and collagen-induced arthritis in mice [12,20] suggesting an infection may lead heightened pro-inflammatory conditions in *0401/DQ8 mice but in *0402/DQ8 mice. Even though all transgenics primed with ESAT6-31-45 peptide generated a similar response to LPS in vitro. We have recently shown that T cells from *0402 and *0401 mice can be driven to produce IFNγ  but kinetics of cytokine responses differ between the two molecules. In this study, ESAT-6-31 primed *0402 mice produced lower amounts of IFNg compared to *0401 though the difference was not statistically different due to variability in individual mouse. The variability in response may be similar to what is observed in humans. A comparison of IFN-γ production in single and haplotype transgenic mice confirmed that DR molecules can modulate DQ-restricted response as *0402/DQ8 mice had much lower levels of IFN-γ as compared to DQ8 mice. A previous study has shown no difference in LPS-induced chemokine production in severe compared to limited TB patients .
While all the transgenic mice tested here generated a response to ESAT-6 31-45, only *0401 and DQ8 mice generated a response to CFP-10 derived peptide 41-60. None of the mice generated response to CFP-10, suggesting it to be a weaker immunogenic peptide than ESAT-6. All mice produced IFN-γ in response to LPS although *0402 and *0402/DQ8 mice generated a much lower cytokine response. Our studies are in confirmation of the previous report that showed β57-Asp HLA-DQ molecules have reduced binding to ESAT-6-46-60 and harbor a lower number of IFN-γ secreting T cells compared to β57Ala . Even though the TLR4-mediated response is generated via the innate immune system, it is indirectly under the control of class II molecules.
In a comparison of sequences identified previously  and the present results, the common sequences in peptides generating a response are 42-45 “AWGG”. Tryptophan is a strong binder for peptide pocket 1 of DR molecules  providing an explanation why this peptide is promiscuous and suggesting this peptide to be a good option for vaccine. Our data suggests that variability in efficacy to BCG, in part, may be due to the host genetic factors. HLA transgenic mice provide a powerful means to study the epitope that may generate protective immunity as well as define the pathogenic epitopes of Mtb. The humanized mice may also be a good tool to study the efficacy of various available and new drugs for tuberculosis.
Authors thank Julie Hanson for the generation and maintenance of the transgenic mice. VT is supported by the NIH grant AR30752.
Cite this article: Veena T. Immune Response to Immunodominant Mycobacterium tuberculosis Antigen ESAT-6 Derived Peptide
is HLA-Haplotype Dependent. J J Aller Immuno. 2014, 1(1): 002.